White Elephant Draw Order Without Drama: Let a Charades Round Pick Who Goes First

The fairest way to settle who goes first in a white elephant swap is to let a quick charades round decide it: split the group into teams, play one fast round of clean office words, and let the winning team pick its draw numbers first. Everybody gets a turn in the spotlight, the room warms up before the first gift is opened, and nobody can say the order was rigged. You can run the whole thing in the free charades game with a timer and teams on one phone, with no app and no signup.
Below is the full plan: why draw order causes so much grumbling, the exact game settings, four ways to turn the scores into a draw order, worked examples for groups from 6 to 40 people, host scripts, and fixes for the things that usually go sideways.
Why "Who Goes First" Starts Arguments at a Gift Swap
A white elephant swap (also called a Yankee swap) looks simple. Everyone brings one wrapped gift, everyone draws a number, and people take turns opening a new gift or stealing one that's already open. The trouble is that the number you draw shapes your whole experience of the game.
Here's how it usually plays out under the most common house rules:
| Draw position | What happens | How people feel about it |
|---|---|---|
| Number 1 | Opens the first gift with nothing to steal | Often the least popular spot, unless your rules give number 1 a final swap |
| Early numbers (2 to 4) | Few open gifts to choose from, high chance of being stolen from | Mixed: you see a gift early but rarely keep it |
| Middle numbers | A decent pile of open gifts to steal from | Comfortable, low drama |
| Late numbers | Can steal almost anything that's been opened | The most wanted spots in most groups |
| Last number | Sees every gift but one before choosing | Usually the single most wanted number |
That table explains the grumbling. When numbers come out of a hat, one person ends up with the last spot and someone else gets stuck with number 1 again, "just like last year." People joke about it, but the joke has an edge, especially at work, where folks already keep a quiet tally of who gets the good projects and the good parking.
There's a second problem, and it's the one hosts notice first. Coworkers who barely know each other stand around holding plates, waiting for the swap to start. The first ten minutes feel stiff. Nobody wants to be the first to laugh loudly, and the person who opens gift number one does it to a silent room.
A short charades round fixes both problems at once. It gets people moving and laughing, and it turns the draw order into something the group earned together instead of something a hat handed out.
The final-swap rule changes who wants what
Many groups add a rule that number 1 gets one last chance at the end of the game to swap their gift for any other open gift. With that rule, number 1 suddenly becomes a strong spot, because that person gets the last word. Some groups also let the last player steal from anyone.
Before you run the charades round, decide which rules you're using and say them out loud. The winning team needs to know what it's choosing between. If number 1 gets the final swap, the smart pick might be the very first number. If it doesn't, the smart pick is almost always the last number. That little bit of strategy is part of the fun.
Why a game beats a hat
A hat is random, but random doesn't always feel fair. People remember streaks. A game feels fair for three reasons:
- Everyone had a chance to affect the result. Your team's acting and guessing moved your team up or down.
- The rules are visible. The timer, the scores and the order of play all happen on one screen that everyone can see.
- It's a team result, not a personal one. If your team lands in last place, you're in it together, and it's hard to stay annoyed when you're laughing about how nobody guessed "stapler."
The Plan at a Glance
This is a 10 to 15 minute warm-up that slots in right after people arrive and right before the first gift is opened. Here's the full timeline for a group of about 16 people.
| Step | Time | What happens |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Gifts on the table, rules announced | 2 minutes | Host explains the swap rules and the plan |
| 2. Make teams | 2 minutes | Count off into 4 teams, mixing departments |
| 3. Charades round | 6 to 8 minutes | Each team gets turns of 30 seconds with Office words |
| 4. Read the final scores | 1 minute | Teams are ranked first to last |
| 5. Pick draw numbers | 2 to 3 minutes | Teams choose numbers in rank order |
| 6. Start the swap | right away | Number 1 opens the first gift |
You need almost nothing:
- One phone or tablet with the free charades game, charged
- Sticky notes or slips of paper with the numbers 1 to however many people are playing
- A pen
- A wall, door or table to stick the numbers on
That's it. No props, no printing, no buzzers.
Why teams, not individuals
You could have every single person act one word and rank all of them, but with 20 people that's 20 turns and a lot of standing around. Teams keep it quick. The charades game supports 2, 3 or 4 teams, and four teams is the sweet spot for most office swaps. With four teams, the game ranks them first, second, third and fourth on the final screen, and that ranking becomes your draw order.
Teams also take the pressure off shy people. Not everyone has to act. A team of five might send one brave actor per turn while the other four guess. Someone who hates being watched can still help by shouting the right answer, which often feels better than acting anyway.
How to mix the teams
The fastest and fairest method is counting off. Stand in a loose circle and have people say "1, 2, 3, 4, 1, 2, 3, 4" around the room. Everyone who said "1" is on Team 1, and so on. Counting off naturally breaks up the cliques that form by the snack table, so the accounting folks end up acting next to the warehouse crew. That mixing is half the point of an icebreaker.
If your group is very uneven in size, don't stress. A team of five against a team of four is fine. The timer is the same for everyone, and a slightly bigger team doesn't get extra turns, only extra guessers.
How to Do It With the Free Tool
Open the charades game generator on the phone you'll pass around. The link opens with the Office category ready to go. On the Set Up Your Game screen, use these settings.
| Setting | What to choose | Why |
|---|---|---|
| How Many Teams? | 4 Teams (3 for groups under 12, 2 for groups under 7) | Four ranked teams make the cleanest draw order |
| Team names | Short and fun, all different | The game asks for a unique name for each team |
| Pick a Category | Office | Clean, work-friendly words everyone can act |
| โ๏ธ Add Custom Words | 8 to 15 gift-swap words (list below) | Adds holiday flavor to the round |
| โฑ๏ธ Timer per Turn | 30 sec | Keeps the whole round under 10 minutes |
| ๐ Rounds | 3 Rounds | The shortest game setting |
| ๐ช Difficulty | ๐ Easy for mixed crowds, ๐ฒ Mixed for a sharp group | Easy keeps everyone scoring |
Then tap ๐ญ Start Playing!
What each setting does in this game
Teams. The game starts at 3 teams, so tap 4 Teams if you want four. Type a name in each box. Each name can be up to 20 characters, and the game won't start if two teams share a name. Quick ideas that work for a gift swap: Wrapping Paper, Tape Dispensers, Bow Thieves, Gift Grabbers, Re-Gifters, Ribbon Wranglers. For more, there's a list of charades team names you can borrow from.
Category. The Office category has words like Printer, Meeting, Laptop, Deadline, Sticky Notes and Stapler at the easy level, and longer ones like Performance Review, Water Cooler Chat and Brainstorming Session at the medium level. On ๐ค Hard you get office jargon like Circling Back and Low-Hanging Fruit, which is very funny to watch someone act but slow to guess. For a warm-up, stay on Easy or Mixed.
Custom words. Tap โ๏ธ Add Custom Words (optional), type a word, and tap + Add or press Enter. Your words get shuffled in with the Office words. This is where you add gift-swap words like "stealing a present" or "ugly holiday sweater." Add them before people gather so nobody waits on you to type.
Timer. The game offers 30 sec, 60 sec, 90 sec or 2 min. For a warm-up, choose 30 sec. Short turns keep energy up, keep any one person from being stuck on stage too long, and keep the swap on schedule.
Rounds. The game offers 3, 5, 7 or 10 rounds, and one round means every team gets one turn. With four teams and 30-second turns, 3 rounds is 12 turns, which takes about 8 minutes including passing the phone. If you're short on time, you can stop early: after the last team finishes its first turn, the Current Scores screen shows where everyone stands, and you can use that ranking instead of finishing all three rounds.
Difficulty. Easy draws only from the easy Office words (plus your custom words). Mixed pulls from easy, medium and hard. Hard pulls only from the hard list. For a group of coworkers who don't know each other well, Easy is the safe pick. Nobody wants to stand in front of the regional manager failing to act "paradigm shift."
How a turn works on the phone
- The game shows a colored pass screen with the team's name. Hand the phone to that team's actor.
- The actor makes sure nobody else can see the screen and taps โถ We're Ready! A short 3-2-1 countdown plays.
- A word appears with the timer running. The actor acts it out with no talking. Only their own team guesses.
- When a teammate shouts the right answer, the actor taps โ GOT IT! and a new word appears right away.
- If a word is a dud, the actor taps โท Skip โ too hard! Skips don't cost points, so encourage people to skip fast.
- When time runs out, the Time's Up screen shows how many words the team got, then Current Scores, then Next Team's Turn โ.
One point per correct word. In a 30-second turn, a team that skips quickly and guesses fast can score three or four. A team that gets stuck on one word might score zero. That spread is good, because it gives you a clear ranking.
When the last round ends, the final screen ranks the teams from first to last with medals and point totals. Take a photo of that screen or read it out. That's your draw order.
Who acts on each turn
Let each team pick a new actor every round, so three rounds means three different people act. Small teams can repeat. If someone really doesn't want to act, they don't have to, but ask them to be the team's official "guesser in chief," which keeps them involved.
A good rule for coworkers: the actor can stop at any time. If someone freezes, they can tap Skip, or hand the phone to a teammate mid-turn. Making it easy to bow out keeps the round light, and it's the reason almost everybody ends up trying.
Turning the Scores Into a Draw Order
Here's where the charades round pays off. Once the game ranks the teams, you need a simple, visible way to turn that ranking into numbers. Pick one of these four methods and announce it before the round starts, not after. Announcing it after the scores are in is how arguments start.
Method 1: The pick board (most popular)
Write the numbers 1 through your player count on sticky notes and stick them on a wall or door, face up, in order. The team that finished first walks up and each member takes the number they want. Then the second-place team picks from what's left, then third, then fourth.
This is the method most groups like best, because the winners get a real reward and everyone can see what's still available. It's also fast. Each team gets 30 to 60 seconds to choose.
Inside the team, who picks first? Keep it light. The person who acted in the final round picks first, or the team does a quick rock-paper-scissors. Don't let it turn into a second contest.
Method 2: Snake order
If you worry that the winning team will grab every late number, use a snake. The first-place team takes one number, then second, third, fourth, then back the other way: fourth, third, second, first, and so on until all numbers are gone. This spreads the good spots across teams while still rewarding the winners with the very first pick.
Snake order takes a little longer and works best when a host calls out each pick, but it feels very fair and it's great for groups that get competitive.
Method 3: Winners choose the block
Split the numbers into blocks the size of each team. With 16 people and four teams of four, the blocks are 1 to 4, 5 to 8, 9 to 12 and 13 to 16. The first-place team chooses which block it wants. Second place chooses from the remaining three blocks, and so on. Inside each block, team members draw slips from a cup.
This is the quickest method for big groups, because only four decisions get made in public.
Method 4: Team rank equals draw order
The simplest version: everyone on the first-place team draws a number from the hat, but only from the latest numbers. With 20 players and four teams of five, first place draws from 16 to 20, second from 11 to 15, third from 6 to 10, and last place draws from 1 to 5. No decisions, no strategy, just a clear reward.
If your group uses the final-swap rule for number 1, you can flip it, or let the winning team call "early or late" before you hand out blocks.
Comparing the four methods
| Method | Time to finish | Best for | Watch out for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pick board | 2 to 3 minutes | Groups of 8 to 25 | Winners may grab all the late numbers |
| Snake order | 3 to 5 minutes | Competitive groups | Needs one person calling picks |
| Winners choose the block | 1 to 2 minutes | Large groups, 25 and up | Less choice inside each block |
| Rank equals draw order | 1 minute | Groups who just want it settled | No strategy, which some people miss |
Worked Examples for Different Group Sizes
Every office and family gathering is a different size. Here's exactly how the plan works for five common groups.
Example 1: Small team of 7
Seven people is too small for four teams. Choose 2 Teams with names like "Bows" and "Ribbons" (one team of 4, one of 3), Office category, 30 sec, 3 Rounds, ๐ Easy. That's six turns, about 4 minutes.
Use the pick board with a twist: the winning team picks its four numbers first, then the other team takes the remaining three. With only seven gifts, the late numbers matter a lot, so the winners will probably take 7, 6 and 5. That's fine. The losing team still gets number 1, and if you use the final-swap rule, that's a strong consolation prize.
Example 2: Department of 12
Choose 3 Teams of four. Office category, 30 sec, 3 Rounds, ๐ Easy plus 10 custom gift-swap words. That's nine turns, about 6 minutes.
Use the snake order. First place picks one number, second picks one, third picks one, then third, second, first, and back again until all 12 are gone. Each team ends up with a spread of early, middle and late numbers, but the winners always got the first choice in each lap.
Example 3: Office party of 16
This is the classic setup from the plan above. 4 Teams of four, Office category, 30 sec, 3 Rounds, ๐ฒ Mixed or ๐ Easy. Twelve turns, about 8 minutes.
Say the final screen shows Bow Thieves first with 9 points, Re-Gifters second with 7, Tape Dispensers third with 7 and Gift Grabbers fourth with 4. Two teams tied at 7 points, but the final screen still lists them in an order. Don't let the screen break the tie on its own; see the tie fix in the troubleshooting section. Once the tie is settled, use the pick board: Bow Thieves pick four numbers, then the second-place team, and so on.
Example 4: Big group of 32
With 32 people, four teams of eight is a lot of guessers per team, which is actually great for energy. Use 4 Teams, Office category, 30 sec, 3 Rounds. If you want more people to act, run 5 Rounds instead. Five rounds is 20 turns, about 13 minutes, and lets five people per team take a turn.
Use the block method. Blocks are 1 to 8, 9 to 16, 17 to 24 and 25 to 32. First place chooses a block, then second, then third, and last place takes what's left. Inside each block, members draw slips from a cup. Big groups need fast decisions, and four public choices keep it moving.
Example 5: Family swap of 10 with kids and grandparents
Gift swaps aren't only for offices. For a family gathering, switch the category to Christmas instead of Office, choose 2 Teams (one team of 5, one of 5), 60 sec timers so younger and older players aren't rushed, 3 Rounds and ๐ Easy. That's six turns, about 7 minutes.
Mix ages on each team, so a grandparent and a nine-year-old can act together. Use the snake order, because family groups care more about everyone getting a mix of numbers than about a big reward for the winners.
Quick reference by group size
| Players | Teams | Timer | Rounds | Acting time | Best draw method |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 5 to 7 | 2 | 30 sec | 3 | About 4 minutes | Pick board |
| 8 to 12 | 3 | 30 sec | 3 | About 6 minutes | Snake order |
| 13 to 24 | 4 | 30 sec | 3 | About 8 minutes | Pick board or snake |
| 25 to 40 | 4 | 30 sec | 3 or 5 | 8 to 13 minutes | Winners choose the block |
| Family, mixed ages | 2 | 60 sec | 3 | About 7 minutes | Snake order |
The acting times include about 10 to 15 seconds for passing the phone between turns. Your group may be faster or slower, so plan a couple of minutes of wiggle room before you need to start the swap.
Office-Safe Gift Swap Words to Add
The Office category already gives you plenty of work-friendly words. Adding 8 to 15 holiday and gift-swap words makes the round feel like part of the party. Everything here is clean, easy to act and safe for a mixed room.
Gift swap words
- Wrapping a gift
- Shaking a present
- Stealing a present
- Hiding a gift behind your back
- Tying a bow
- Peeling off tape
- Opening a tiny box
- Re-gifting
- Gift receipt
- Fake smile at a bad gift
- Ugly holiday sweater
- Scented candle
- Novelty mug
- Socks as a gift
- Puzzle with a missing piece
Holiday office words
- Office party
- Holiday cookies in the break room
- Decorating a cubicle
- Paper snowflake
- Hanging lights on a desk
- Out-of-office reply
- Snow day
- Last meeting before the holidays
- Stringing popcorn
- Building a snowman in the parking lot
- Hot cocoa
- Cutting a sheet cake
Words that make people laugh without crossing a line
- Reply all
- Printer jam
- Muted on a video call
- Microwave popcorn smell
- Losing your badge
- Typing in all caps
- Elevator small talk
- Tripping over a cable
- Desk chair spin
- Keyboard full of crumbs
For a bigger pool of work-friendly words you can use at other events, the office party charades list has dozens more sorted by difficulty.
Words to leave out at work
A white elephant swap brings together people from different teams, ages and backgrounds. Skip anything that could put a coworker on the spot.
- Anything about specific people in the room, including the boss by name
- Jokes about layoffs, reviews or pay
- Body-related words that might embarrass someone
- Anything about partying late or overdoing it
- Religious scenes, unless you know everyone is comfortable with them
- Inside jokes only one department will get
The rule of thumb: if you'd hesitate to act it in front of the newest person on the team, don't add it.
Host Scripts That Keep It Light
How you announce the plan sets the mood. You want people to feel the game is fair, fast and silly, not a competition they'll be judged on. Here's a script you can read almost word for word.
When people arrive
"Hi everyone, grab a snack and put your gift on the table. Before we start the swap, we're going to settle the draw order the fair way, with a quick round of charades. It takes about ten minutes, nobody has to act if they really don't want to, and the winning team gets first pick of the numbers."
That one paragraph answers the three things people worry about: how long it takes, whether they'll be forced to perform, and what's at stake.
Explaining the swap rules
"Here are our swap rules. When it's your turn, you can open a new gift or steal one that's already open. If your gift gets stolen, you can open a new one or steal from someone else, but you can't steal right back the gift that was just taken from you. A gift is frozen after it's been stolen three times. And number 1 gets one last swap at the very end."
Change these to match your group's rules. The point is to say them before the charades round so the winners know what they're picking.
Making teams
"Let's count off by fours, starting with me. One, two, three, four... Okay, all the ones over here by the window, twos by the door, threes by the snacks, fours by the tree."
Explaining the round
"Each team gets three turns of 30 seconds. One person acts, the rest of your team guesses. No talking, no pointing at things in the room. If your word is too hard, hit Skip, there's no penalty. Most points wins."
Announcing the results
"And the winners are... Bow Thieves, with nine points! Bow Thieves, come up to the board and pick your numbers. Everyone else, start plotting."
Keep the energy up here. A little drumroll on the table goes a long way.
Starting the swap
"Okay, number 1, come on up. You're opening the first gift of the day. No pressure."
Then step back and let the swap run. The room is warm now, people have laughed together, and nobody's arguing about whose number came out of the hat.
When Something Goes Sideways
Even a good plan runs into a few bumps. These are the most common ones at office and family swaps, with fixes that take seconds.
| Problem | What it looks like | Quick fix |
|---|---|---|
| Two teams tie | Final screen says "It's a Tie!" or two teams share a score | One sudden-death word each: start a new game with just those 2 teams, 30 sec, and stop after the first round. Higher score wins; if still tied, rock-paper-scissors |
| Nobody wants to act first | Long awkward pause after the host hands over the phone | The host acts the very first word as a demo, unscored. It shows how silly it's okay to be |
| Someone feels left out | One person stays at the back of the room | Make them the team's guesser in chief, or the official number caller at the pick board |
| Teams argue about the draw method | "That's not fair, we should do snake order!" | Announce the method before the round starts, and stick to it |
| Running out of time | The party has a hard stop and you're behind | Stop after the first round and use the Current Scores screen as the ranking |
| A word is confusing | "What does circling back even look like?" | Tap Skip, and switch difficulty to ๐ Easy next time |
| Shouting gets too loud | Neighboring offices start peeking in | Only the acting team may guess out loud; other teams must stay quiet |
| Someone peeks at the screen | A guesser sees the word over the actor's shoulder | Actor stands with their back to a wall; the peeking team loses their next turn's first word |
| Someone joins late | A coworker shows up after the round | Give them a number from the leftover slips, or let them join the last-place team before picks |
Variations for Different Crowds
The basic plan works for most groups, but these adjustments help when your gathering looks a little different.
Coworkers who don't know each other well
Lean easy. Use ๐ Easy difficulty, short 30-second turns, and plenty of simple custom words like "wrapping a gift" and "snow day." Mix departments on every team. Let people bow out of acting without a fuss. For more low-pressure ideas you can use before or after the swap, see these icebreaker games for work.
Teams who play every year
If this is a long-running office tradition, raise the stakes a little. Use ๐ฒ Mixed difficulty, so the round includes office jargon like Moving the Needle. Keep a paper list of which team won each year and tape it to the gift table. The game doesn't save results, so the paper list becomes part of the tradition.
Hybrid or remote swaps
When some people join by video, the actor needs to be on camera and the word needs to stay private. The actor can open the game on their own phone and keep it out of view while they act. Remote teams guess in the chat or by unmuting. For setup tips, the guide to virtual charades walks through it step by step. The number pick works the same way: share a simple list of numbers on screen and let teams claim them in rank order.
Family gift swaps with kids
Use the Christmas category, 60 or 90 sec timers and ๐ Easy difficulty. Pair younger kids with an older relative on each turn. Make sure kids know the swap rules before they pick numbers, because some children get upset when a gift is stolen. A family can also add a gentle rule: children's gifts can be stolen only once.
Your swap-day checklist
- Decide your swap rules, including whether number 1 gets a final swap.
- Decide your draw method: pick board, snake order, blocks or rank order.
- Write numbers on sticky notes, one per player.
- Open the charades game and set it up before guests arrive: 4 Teams (fewer for small groups), Office category, 30 sec, 3 Rounds, ๐ Easy.
- Add 8 to 15 gift-swap words with โ๏ธ Add Custom Words.
- Read the arrival script, make teams by counting off, and play the round.
- Read the final scores, settle any tie, and let teams pick their numbers in order.
- Start the swap.
If you want a few more ideas to fill the rest of the party once the gifts are open, there's a roundup of the best office Christmas party games that pair well with a swap.
Happy swapping, and may the best gift land on your side of the room.
Frequently Asked Questions
In a white elephant swap, who goes first?
The person who draws number 1 goes first and opens the first gift. Because there's nothing to steal yet, many groups see it as the weakest spot unless number 1 gets a final swap at the end. Letting a short charades round decide which team picks numbers first makes the whole order feel earned instead of random.
Is it better to go first or last in white elephant?
Under most house rules, going last is better, because you can see and steal almost every gift. If your group gives number 1 a final swap at the end, the first spot becomes strong too. Tell everyone which rule you use before numbers are picked.
How long does the charades warm-up take?
With four teams, 30-second turns and 3 rounds, plan on about 8 minutes of play, plus a few minutes to make teams and pick numbers. In a hurry, stop after the first round and use the Current Scores screen as your ranking. That version takes about 3 minutes.
What category should I use for coworkers?
Use the Office category. It has work-friendly words like Printer, Deadline, Sticky Notes and Brainstorming Session. Add a handful of your own gift-swap words with โ๏ธ Add Custom Words so the round feels festive, and keep the difficulty on ๐ Easy for mixed groups.
How many teams can the charades game handle?
The game supports 2, 3 or 4 teams. For bigger parties, make larger teams rather than more teams, or run two separate games in two areas of the room and combine the rankings.
What if two teams tie?
Run a quick sudden-death game with only the two tied teams, set to 30 sec, and stop after each team has had one turn. Higher score wins. If they're still tied, the team captains play rock-paper-scissors.
Does everyone have to act?
No. Teams choose one actor per turn, and anyone who doesn't want to act can guess instead. Most shy people end up happy to shout answers, and some decide to try acting once they see how silly everyone else is being.
Can we use this for a family gift exchange, not just work?
Yes. Switch the category to Christmas, use 60-second turns so kids and grandparents aren't rushed, and put mixed ages on each team. The snake order works well for families because everyone ends up with a mix of early and late numbers.



